Usually, Nintendo is seen as a company that maintains absolute authority over its creations. It designs and manufactures its own consoles, which are primarily bought to experience in-house Nintendo games. Such complete mastery is uncommon in both technology and entertainment; maybe only giants like Disney or Apple compare.
The Glaring Anomaly: Pokémon
But, there exists one glaring exception to this model. Pokémon is arguably Nintendo's biggest property. Some estimates, albeit hard to confirm, claim it is the top-earning media franchise in history. This fortune flows from omnipresent merchandise, game sales, and a booming card game business. But interestingly, Pokémon is not entirely Nintendo's property.
The mainline Pokémon games are released only on Nintendo consoles, but they are made by the external studio Game Freak. Together with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the company behind the trading card game), Nintendo co-owns The Pokémon Company. This entity oversees the worldwide merchandising business that brings in multibillions. Furthermore, the massive hit Pokémon Go was created and published by external studios under a license from The Pokémon Company, operating at a considerable remove from Nintendo's immediate oversight.
In fact, the phenomenal popularity of Pokémon in the 1990s and 2000s had a notable forerunner.
In 1989, Nintendo launched the groundbreaking Game Boy. However, its internal teams had not yet discovered the ideal application for it. That answer came in the shape of the licensed title Tetris. Nintendo's determined quest to secure the rights for the Game Boy version of Tetris is the stuff of legend in the gaming world. Tetris enabled Nintendo to establish and rule the handheld console arena for decades. This portable business provided crucial stability during difficult periods for its console business and eventually culminated in the versatile Switch.
The Genesis of a Sensation
Although Nintendo created excellent handheld versions of Mario and Zelda, a truly original idea for a perfect portable game eluded its top creators. Instead, that inspiration came from former game journalist Satoshi Tajiri, creator of Game Freak. Upon learning that Game Boys could be connected via a cable, he envisioned exchanging digital beings, drawing from his youthful experiences of collecting insects.
Nintendo recognized the potential in the pitch from Game Freak and gave it the green light. Yet, it required a long time for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the sprawling RPG released in 1996. Another couple of years passed before the titles, coupled with a card game and an animated series, exploded into a global craze. Pokémon prolonged the life of the Game Boy well into its 14-year run and essentially guaranteed Nintendo's financial security.
Why Not Buy It All?
It may appear strange that Nintendo did not move to fully purchase Game Freak and Pokémon when its massive potential became clear. A more aggressive company would have likely sought a total takeover. Instead, the three-way alliance between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was formalized as soon as 1998. This evolved into The Pokémon Company, which today manages the worldwide brand.
Nintendo has a tradition of tight-knit, enduring collaborations with chosen external studios, such as HAL Laboratory and Intelligent Systems, yet acquiring them. But, Pokémon's success was of a different magnitude. Why then not seize the whole pie? Perhaps the founding minds behind Pokémon refused to give up total ownership. It is also possible that Nintendo's leadership, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the shrewd Satoru Iwata, made a conscious choice not to seek complete acquisition.
The Benefits of Separation
In hindsight, this setup may have been remarkably shrewd. Would Nintendo have sanctioned the enormous range of licensed products or dived into the trading card market with such abandon? The Pokémon Company, operating with a measure of autonomy, could execute a rapacious plan to claim global mindshare and revenue.
This separation allowed Nintendo to enjoy the financial rewards while staying somewhat shielded from the periodic backlashes related to the franchise. When concerns emerged about the trading card game influence, the focus was directed elsewhere from Nintendo. Also, the sometimes variable reception of modern Game Freak games is a public relations cost largely borne by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo directly.
A Lasting Symbiosis
Perhaps this distinct relationship with Pokémon is quintessentially Nintendo in the end. The company is known for not fixing what works.|Nintendo generally avoids unnecessary